Experts Challenge MTA Studies of Subway Routes

Scientists hired by the city claim more thorough research is needed to justify Metro's plans for a tunnel under Beverly Hills High School.

Experts in engineering and seismology on Tuesday told the City Council a more complete study and risk assessment should be done before the Metropolitan Transportation Authority makes a final decision on the route of the Westside Subway Extension.

"More studies are needed to justify selection of station location and tunnel alignment," according to a presentation by Piotr Moncarz, project manager for Exponent. "A quantifiable measure of risk should be made using a risk-based methodology for each station option."

Exponent's analysis is a peer review of an October 2011 safety assessment by MTA consultants who compared the possibility of placing a subway station on Santa Monica Boulevard or Constellation Boulevard in Century City. The Constellation Boulevard stop would entail running a subway tunnel beneath as well as residences and businesses located in the city's western vicinity.

"Based on the findings reported in the Metro-sponsored reports and supporting review comments, momentum seems to be building against construction of a station on Santa Monica Boulevard based on perceived fault rupture hazards," Exponent said in its report. The company, however, noted potential dangers with both possible locations.

"It is Exponent’s view that the alternative Constellation Boulevard station, while generally in a more favorable location with regards to faulting issues, is instead faced with potential methane gas hazards that could represent at least as great a hazard to the public as the faulting hazards associated with the Santa Monica Boulevard station."

Moncarz and seismology expert Phillip Shaller highlighted several key concerns about the thoroughness of the MTA-commissioned study at the council study session. These concerns included:

  • Questionable assessment of active earthquake faults near the proposed tunnel alignments;
  • "Undocumented oil well castings" from a potential slew of abandoned metal oil well shafts under the high school that could significantly hinder tunnel drilling;
  • The Metro study's "limited consideration of soil settlement" after tunneling and how that could impact overlying buildings and infrastructure.

Moncarz also pointed to 2009 MTA documentation indicating a potentially dangerous pocket of methane gas along the Constellation route, and he noted the failure of Metro's consultants to properly assess the level of risk associated with tunneling in such a location. Moncarz said the Metro report contains assumptions that dismiss concerns about possible danger that aren't backed by thorough ground testing or quantifiable risk assessment methodology.

In response to Exponent's critique, Metro CEO Arthur Leahy sent a dated Feb. 7 to council members and City Manager Jeff Kolin. Leahy countered, "It should be noted that the subway has operated for nearly 20 years in a methane gas area in downtown Los Angeles without incident."

The final environmental impact report of the MTA's plans, upon which the agency will base its final decision of the route, will be released later this year, according to Leahy.

Be sure to follow Beverly Hills Patch on Twitter and "Like" us on Facebook.

Brian David Goldberg, PhD February 10, 2012 at 02:08 AM
This report only serves as further proof that the MTA is ignoring the science when it does not support their desired outcome. The seismic work being conduct by BHUSD coupled with this report provides a one two punch to MTA claims about the science and their safety claims.
Simon February 12, 2012 at 03:05 AM
Um, no, Dr. Goldberg. Ur own bought and paid for experts admit Constellation is favorable when it comes to fault issues, and the subway already operates in methane areas (in downtown). I hope u all r drummed out of office for wasting everyone's time and money. I hear a Facebook page starting somewhere...
John Mirisch February 12, 2012 at 07:05 AM
Goldberg just won reelection by one of the largest margins in School Board history. He's not going anywhere, much to the benefit of Beverly Hills. Interesting how Sy calls Exponent (paid for by the City, not the District) "bought and paid for," but the Metro experts, despite the fact that they were paid by Metro, are evidently legit. Exponent has called for a risk analysis and more information. By the way, not only does the subway operate in methane areas, it also operates in earthquake areas (all over). It's clear you'd like everyone to simply say "amen" and perhaps "thank you, sir, may I have another" to whatever Big Government says, but, fortunately, there is an entire Community which is willing to stand up to a massive government agency which evidently feels it can do whatever it wants, with no transparency and no accountability. Great subject for a Facebook page, if you ask me.
joninla February 14, 2012 at 06:28 AM
I wondered who drunk all the "Kool-Aide". Now I know. Never blog and drink at the same time, or people with think you actually believe your own irrational statements. (a tip to the not wise)


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »